Best Restaurants In Sag Harbor (My Top 9 Places)

About the author

Travel author

Charles

I have a passion for the English countryside and especially anywhere in Yorkshire. I drink far too much Yorkshire tea on my travels and even take it with me when abroad. My passion is to share travel experiences with my readers which may help them plan their holidays and save money.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases

As a regular visitor to Sag Harbor I believe I can recommend a few must-visit restaurants in.

I have curated a diverse selection of restaurants that span a range of culinary styles.

These venues draw inspiration from various cuisines.

Each restaurant’s skilled chefs infuse cultural influences and distinctive flavor combinations into their delectable recipes.

#9. Best American Restaurant: Claudio’s Tavern & Grill

This culinary gem invites you to savor the essence of coastal America with a delectable array of dishes inspired by the New England tradition of fresh seafood.

Dive into a world where quality ingredients take center stage, handpicked to create succulent masterpieces that truly captivate your palate.

Find out which is the better travel destination? East Hampton NY vs. South Hampton NY

#8. Best Seafood Restaurant: Beacon 

Beacon, a local favorite, has served delicious seafood for over 20 years.

With a diverse menu catering to all budgets, from affordable seafood sandwiches to high-end combos, you’ll surely find something you love.

And with waterfront dining in the Hamptons, the sunset ambiance is a bonus.

For ladies – What to wear to the Hamptons?

#7. Best Italian Restaurant: Dopo La Spiaggia

DOPO La Spiaggia is hands down the best Italian restaurant in Sag Harbor.

The menu features exquisite Tuscan cuisine focusing on fresh seafood and handmade pasta.

From classics like spaghetti carbonara to unique dishes like black tagliolini with lobster, every bite is a delightful journey to Italy. Their extensive wine list will leave you wanting more.

#6. Best Asian Fusion Restaurant: Sen

Located just a stone’s throw away from Sag Harbor’s bustling Main Street, Sen is a highly acclaimed Asian fusion restaurant that surpasses expectations.

This hidden gem specializes in a delectable array of sushi and authentic Japanese cuisine.

#5. Best Mediterranean Restaurant: Lulu Kitchen & Bar

Lulu Kitchen and Bar provides a distinctive dining affair, focusing on Mediterranean cuisine and the fine craft of wood-fired cooking.

The establishment prides itself on using the finest and locally sourced ingredients to ensure an unparalleled and authentic dining experience.

Guests can relish an authentic assortment of raw bar items and delectable dishes expertly prepared on the restaurant’s wood fire grill.

#4. Best Mexican Restaurant: K Pasa

K Pasa is an absolute gem when it comes to Mexican cuisine.

The restaurant draws inspiration from the relaxed beach lifestyle found in the east end, Laguna Beach, and Malibu. This popular spot offers a variety of tacos, tequila, and rosé wines perfect for sharing.

#3. Best Vegetarian Restaurant: Estia’s Little Kitchen

This delightful spot is perfect for a summer lunch. The back garden creates a serene oasis that will melt your heart.

They offer two delectable vegan options: a veggie burrito and a veggie bowl. The burrito is jam-packed with a variety of vegetables and beans, accompanied by a refreshing side of slaw salad.

#2. Best Brunch Spot: Bird on the Roof & Eatery

Known for its mouthwatering dishes, such as avocado toast with a twist and fluffy pancakes, Bird on The Roof never fails to impress with its aesthetically pleasing plates and top-notch service.

Whether you’re looking for a relaxed brunch with friends or a special date spot, this is the ultimate choice for an unforgettable experience.

#1. Best Pizza Place: Sam’s Restaurant

What sets Sam’s apart from the rest is the mouthwatering pizzas they create and the unique and innovative toppings that elevate their pies to a whole new level of deliciousness.

From their famous lobster and truffle oil pizza to the surprisingly delectable combination of figs, prosciutto, and gorgonzola.

Should you avoid the peak season? Best time to visit the Hamptons

Final Thoughts

Sag Harbor boasts a wide range of restaurants that cater to all tastes and preferences.

Whether you are looking for traditional American dishes, seafood, or international cuisine, you will find it in Sag Harbor.

With its picturesque waterfront views and charming atmosphere, dining in Sag Harbor is not just about the food but also about the overall experience.

Charles

I have a passion for the English countryside and especially anywhere in Yorkshire. I drink far too much Yorkshire tea on my travels and even take it with me when abroad. My passion is to share travel experiences with my readers which may help them plan their holidays and save money.

Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

Latest posts